Police Benevolent Association of NYC v. City of New York

Decision: n/a
Argument: 2023.10.19 vid. tr.

Whether the Administrative Code of the City of New York § 10-181, which makes it a criminal misdemeanor to use certain methods of restraint in the course of effecting or attempting to affect an arrest, is unconstitutionally vague or preempted by New York State Law.


Appellant’s Brief [PBA]
Appellants’ Brief [Sergeants]
Respondent’s Brief
Reply Brief [PBA]
Reply Brief [Sergeants]
Appellant’s Jurisdiction Letter
Respondent’s Jurisdictional Letter
First Department Decision
Supreme Court Decision
AD1 Appellant’s Brief
AD1 Respondent’s Brief (Plaintiffs)
AD1 Respondent’s Brief (NYC PBA)
AD1 Reply