| Decision: 2023.02.09 |
| Argument: 2023.01.03 vid. tr. |
Whether section 23-2703(3) of the Mined Land Reclamation Law bars the Department of Environmental Conservation from processing the renewal and modification permits sought for a preexisting mine because the local zoning code prohibits mining in the Suffolk County District where the mine is located.
Third Department Decision
Supreme Court Decision
Supreme Court Decision
Appellant’s (merits) Brief – Southampton (AD3)
Appellant’s (merits) Brief – Southampton Civic et al. (AD3)
Respondent’s (merits) Brief – DEC (AD3)
Respondent’s (merits) Brief – Sand Land (AD3)
Appellant’s (merits) Reply – Southampton (AD3)
Appellant’s (merits) Reply – Southampton Civic et al. (AD3)
AMICUS (merits) Brief – East Hampton et al. (AD3)
Appellant’s (merits) Brief – Southampton Civic et al. (AD3)
Respondent’s (merits) Brief – DEC (AD3)
Respondent’s (merits) Brief – Sand Land (AD3)
Appellant’s (merits) Reply – Southampton (AD3)
Appellant’s (merits) Reply – Southampton Civic et al. (AD3)
AMICUS (merits) Brief – East Hampton et al. (AD3)
Appellant’s (intervention) Brief (AD3)
Respondent’s (intervention) Brief – DEC (AD3)
Respondent’s (intervention) Brief – Sand Land (AD3)
Appellant’s (intervention) Reply (AD3)