Decision: 2023.02.14 |
Argument: 2022.01.04 vid. tr. |
Whether PERB’s determination that the imposition of an application fee for promotional examinations was a mandatory subject of negotiation was rational and supported by substantial evidence; whether the Appellate Division applied the appropriate standard of review in resolving a purported question of statutory interpretation; whether PERB lacked authority or jurisdiction over the Department of Civil Service.
Appellant’s Brief
Respondent’s Brief (PERB)
Respondent’s Brief (DC37)
Respondent’s Brief (NYSCOPBA)
Respondent’s Brief (CSEA)
Reply Brief
Respondent’s Brief (PERB)
Respondent’s Brief (DC37)
Respondent’s Brief (NYSCOPBA)
Respondent’s Brief (CSEA)
Reply Brief
Third Department Decision
Supreme Court Decision
Supreme Court Decision
n/a